So, let's get eating.
When I walked into the shop I noticed beer taps. That's right. Even though it was lunch, I was very pleased to see BEER on the menu. What is a good sandwich without a cold, crisp beer? I went with iced tea for my lunch beverage, but I vowed to return and sample the beers.
In an active dining area with about 15 tables, you can hear the music playing and chatter from behind the sandwich counter. Folks return regularly and definitely have their own favorite sandwiches. On a menu that boasts a couple dozen offerings - and a daily special sandwich each weekday - there's plenty to get your attention.
What got my attention was the Atomic Meatloaf Meltdown; the Cubano; and the Cheese sandwich. Here's their description (from the menu) and my take on each.
Atomic Meatloaf Meltdown
Grilled meatloaf, jack cheese, Inner Beauty hot sauce, red-onion jam, on grilled sourdough bread.
This is now in my top five sandwiches of all time. The meatloaf was thick, but even with the grilling it broke apart nicely and was definitely meaty. There was just the right amount of cheese and the grilled bread gave me a tasty vehicle on which to taste the entire symphony of food. What I really liked best about this sandwich was that the hot sauce and the jam played nicely together and gave my mouth a little tingle. Certainly not overpowering, but complemented the meat perfectly. I think that this is a sandwich that combines both some soul and some comfort. I know it did for me.
Virginia baked ham, Mojo braised pork, jack cheese, Swiss cheese, dill pickle, cilantro aioli and Dijon mustard, on pressed french loaf.
It was messy and overstuffed. If you're used to getting a Cuban that is a thin tortilla with scant amounts of meat, this isn't it. There was enough pork on that sandwich to make a second sandwich if I'd been so inclined. The pickle was sliced lengthwise and the mustard and aioli were slathered on. While I resorted to eating it with a knife and fork, it was perfectly balanced from a flavor perspective. The one thing I might have looked for was a little bit seasoning on the pork, but the salt of the ham and the vinegar of the pickle and tang of the mustard made up for that.
Herb-roasted beef, Fontina cheese, Applewood smoked bacon, watercress, balsamic tomato-onion jam, roasted garlic parmesan, pressed on Ciabatta.
Here's where I got confused. When talking with Johnny, I selected the Cheese sandwich and he immediately asked if that was too much meat for me. Especially because I had meatloaf, the Cubano and then this sandwich. I said no, because when reading the menu I thought a cheese sandwich was like a grilled cheese. Not so, mon frere. The cheese sandwich at All-Star is like a roast beef sandwich with the works. The taste was great and the roast beef was done just past medium rare (great consistency), and the cheese and jam definitely come to play. It's maybe best compared to an upscale steak and cheese.
Essentially, something Johnny said to me when I first arrived made total sense when thinking about how these sandwiches were crafted/developed. He said his style of cooking starts with a passion and comes from the heart (so he's thinking about ingredients and the sandwich concept), then it goes to the mind (because he has the imagination to put a new twist on old favorites), and then to the hand (which is his skillset of combining ingredients for balance and taste).
Each of the sandwiches I had met that description and I was pleased to have had the opportunity to have a lunch at his restaurant.
The side for each sandwich was a tiny bowl of cole slaw and a pickle. Both were fresh and crisp.
I didn't have the fries, but they looked good and easily 50% of the diners ordered them, so they must be a favorite.
I saw Poutine on the menu. Made me smile.
Johnny brought out a buffalo chicken finger that was tender and tasty. The sauce had a hint of honey and enough heat to get your attention, but not too much to run your taste buds. I thought the sauce would be great on a pulled pork sandwich. Maybe next time.
The store gets big points for staff attention, beer taps and inventive sandwiches.
The store loses a half a point for the combination of location (not anything they could change now) and the price of a sandwich. Each was around $9 or $10 before adding fries and/or a drink. That puts your lunch bill around $18 a head after tip. While it's worth the price, I felt I should mention it.
Here's that info on the other sandwiches and another photo of Johnny and the kitchen crew.
Banh Mi of Soy-Tangerine Glazed Salmon with Avocado, Carrots, Cucumbers, Sesame Spinach and Sweet Potato-Sriracha Aioli on Grilled Baguette
Gyro of Yogurt & Citrus Marinated Grilled Chicken with Sheep’s Milk Feta, Tomatoes, Onions and Tzasiki Sauce on Grilled Flat Bread
Santorini, Greece (vegetarian)
Oregano-Infused Tomatoes with Feta , Baby Spinach and Eggplant Pesto on Rosemary Focaccia
Torta of Honey-Pasilla Chile Roasted Pork Loin with Queso Blanco Fondue, Grilled Chorizo, Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Fried Poblano Peppers,
Crema Mexicana and Salsa Verde on Grilled Telera Bread
Kalbi (back by popular demand from 2010) of BBQ Braised Short Ribs with House-made Kim Chee, Crispy Won Tons, Fried Egg and
Wasabi-Yuzu Ranch Dressing on Black Pepper Brioche.
Chinese 5 Spice Slow-Roasted Baby Back Rib with Soy-Plum Glaze, Crispy Daikon Slaw, Ginger- Shitake Tapenade and Miso Aioli
Where do you want me to go next? Leave your notes in the comments - and follow me on Twitter at @BostonFoodFan.