Critics loved Elisa in Ten Cents A Dance:
"Also distinctive and delightful is Elisa Winter as the bubbly, overly fresh-as-a-daisy Miss Jones One."
- Bob Rendell, Talkingbroadway.com
"McKechnie, embodying the older, wiser, wistful version of Miss Jones, makes a strong impression, as does Elisa Winter as her youngest predecessor."
- C.W. Walker, NJ Press Media
"...Elisa Winter’s beguiling smiles individually and collectively flavor most of the songs."
- Simon Saltzman, U.S.1
“From the young, bright-eyed Miss Jones One (Elisa Winter) through the increasingly cynical, seasoned and mature representatives of this chorus girl of Johnny’s imagination, the individual performances are perfectly blended into the ensemble.”
- Donald Gilpin, TopicS